Statistics Against Same Sex Adoption Essay

On By In 1

Although gay couples’ legal right to marry has been settled, their right to adopt has not been. While there are no barriers to gay adoption in several states, other jurisdictions put up various legal obstacles. Mississippi and Utah present the most severe barrier; in both states adoptions by homosexuals are illegal.

The arguments against same sex couple adoptions fall into two categories: such adoptions are wrong as a matter of principle and they are wrong because they aren’t good for children.

The principle opposition to gay adoption is that children are entitled to their biological parents who are of the opposite sex. This argument claims that since children are conceived by a man and a woman, children are therefore entitled to a mother and father. This position rules out both single parent adoptions and adoptions by same sex couples.

A strict adherence to this principle becomes incoherent. Should a single mother be forced to marry, for example? Should divorce be ruled out since the child will be separated from at least one of the parents? Should a pregnant woman who decides that she is incapable of raising a child be barred from placing her child up for adoption? There have always been mothers who have chosen to put their babies in the care of others. It would be cruel to both parent and baby to insist that parents must raise their offspring under all circumstances.

Most everyone agrees that everything else being equal, children should remain in their natal family. But things are seldom equal. Parents die or may be abusive, they may disappear or go to prison, they may have a psychiatric disorder so severe they cannot even taken care of themselves. So children will be adopted. If the standard is the best interest of the child, what family configuration is most likely to lead to a healthy child?

Opponents of same sex adoption present stories of adults who were raised in adoptive homes who say they were harmed because they had only one sex as their role model. No doubt some of these individuals are rightfully aggrieved, but the question is whether the harm they felt was worse than that experienced by other adoptees. There the evidence is scant.

For many, if not most, being adopted creates psychological tensions that are absent in those who were raised by their biological parents. But the major groups concerned with children’s health do no oppose gay adoptions because evidence points decisively that being raised by same sex couples is not detrimental to a child’s well being. (The assertion that organizations such a the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, the American Medical Association and the National Association of Social Workers are either intimidated by or are in the thralls of the “gay agenda” is spurious.)

Incidentally, the arguments raised against gay couples adopting are the same as those presented against trans-racial adoptions. Neither the principled or practical arguments against such adoptions have withstood the test of time.

Children may suffer in families for many reasons but being raised by a gay individual or couple is not, in and of itself, one of them. Being adopted is for some so traumatic that nothing can compensate for the loss of the biological connection. Generally, though, love, care, stability, nurturance and respect are enough for a successful upbringing, regardless of whether it is provided by those biological connected, heterosexual or homosexual couples or single parents.

Prospective adoptive parents should be judged on the likelihood that they will provide a loving home for the child. This is the primary consideration, not someone’s sexual orientation.

Adoptions should be guided by what is best for the child—the empirical consideration of whether the home is loving and stable. These are the necessary and sufficient qualifications.

+ All Gay Adoption Essays:

  • The Right to Marriage for the Gays
  • Innovation Diffusion Framework-Policy Adoption
  • Same Sex Relationships
  • Gays in the Military
  • Law Reform
  • Gay Civil Rights
  • Gay Marriage
  • Gay or Lesbian Parenting and the Psychological Effects on Their Adoptive Children
  • Defense of Marriage Act
  • Gay And Lesbians Marriage
  • How Culture Defines the Organization Campus Christian Fellowship and Repudiates Misconceptions
  • Factors and Forces Affecting Ehr System Adoption: Report of a 2004 Acmi Discussion
  • Gay Marriage Research Paper
  • Taking a Look at the Institution of Adoptions
  • Legalizing Gay Marriage
  • Same-sex Rights Should Be a Federal Matter
  • Challenges in Adoption of Ifrs in Nigeria
  • It's Time for Open Adoption
  • Americans' Acceptance of Homosexuality
  • Homosexuality, Nature or Nurture?
  • The Intersection of Race, Sexual Orientation and Religion in the Gay Community
  • Hollywood: Promoting Stereotypes to Make Easy Money
  • An Argument Against Same-Sex Adoption
  • Gay Marriage Should Be Legal
  • Rogers' Diffusion and Adoption Research
  • Nature vs Nurture: Twin Studies and Adoption
  • Strengthening The Foster Care and Adoption System
  • Adoption of Animals
  • Open or Closed Adoption: What is Your Choice?
  • Arguements Against tge Legalization of Gay Marraige
  • Gay Marriage Should be Legal
  • Same-Sex Marriage Should be Legalized
  • The Debate on Homosexuals Adopting Children
  • Gay Marriage
  • Gays in the Military
  • International Adoption
  • The Scapegoating of Homosexuals as Threats to Society
  • The Sound of a Hundred Feathers: The Symbolism of Richard Hook's Painting, Adoption of the Human Race
  • Biracial Adoption
  • Same-Sex Marriage Should Be Legal
  • Lesbian and Gay Teens
  • Gay Dance Clubs
  • The Transracial Adoption and the Multi-Ethnic Placement Act
  • Semantic Change: How Gay Became Homosexual
  • Adoption by Same-Sex Couples
  • Factors Affecting the Adoption of High Performance Work Systems in Foreign Subsidiaries: an Empirical Investigation in Hong Kong
  • Gay Marriage Will Harm Children
  • Trends in Family Formation: A Look at Same-Sex Marriage
  • Same-Sex Parenting
  • Legalize Gay Marriage
  • The Case for Gay Marriage
  • The Disadvantages of Allowing Same Sex Marriages
  • Assessing the View that Family Diversity is Leading to a Weakening of Traditional Family Values
  • Gays/Lesbians Normalization in America
  • The Gay Marriage Controversy
  • Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual Issues - Same-sex Marriage is Inevitable
  • The Debate Over Gay Rights Movement
  • Marriage: Is It Just for a Man and a Woman?
  • Against Legalizing Homosexual Marriages
  • Compare and Contrast Two Views of Gay Marriage
  • Defense of Marriage Act
  • Hate Crimes Against Gays
  • My Invisible Gay Culture
  • Unwanted Children: Adoption and Foster Care in the US
  • Critical essay on gay marriage
  • In a Country of Diversity and Tolerance, Discrimination for Lesbians, Gays, Bisexuals, and Transgender Still Exists
  • The Operations, Problems and Prospect of Pos Adoption in Nigeria
  • Gay Marriage: All Men Are Not Created Equal
  • International Adoption
  • Democratic Morality and the Administrative Law
  • Recognizing Same-Sex Marriage Legally in the United States
  • Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage
  • International Adoption: A Global Problem or a Global Solution?
  • Gay Marriage Ethics Paper
  • The Dirty Truth behind Foreign Adoption
  • Gay Marriage Is a Human Rights Issue
  • Same-Sex Marriage and Adoption Should Be Legal
  • Let Us Legalize Gay Marriage
  • Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Inclusion
  • The Universal Right to Family
  • The Difficulties in Defining the Family
  • We Must Become More Accepting of the LGBT Community
  • Gay Rights: Homosexuals Deserve the same Rights as Heterosexuals
  • Gay Marriage and Religion
  • The Feud Over Gay Marriage
  • The Advantages of Closed Adoption Over Open Adoption
  • Adoption of Ifrs in Bulgaria
  • International Adoption
  • Gay Couples Should Not Be Allowed to Adopt Children
  • The Social Process Theories
  • The Occurrence of Domestic Violence in the Gay and Lesbian Communities

0 comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *